Idol Critic

Ok, I cant hold it in anymore. WHAT is Sanjaya still doing on the show? I just really dont understand it! I think it is doing a complete injustice to the rest of the people on the show, who actually HAVE talent! I really hope that I am not offending any of you that like him. Obviously somebody does, otherwise he wouldnt still be on the show. Oh well, we are all entitled to our own opinions I guess. I just read this article on MSNBC (see below) and it struck me as quite humorous! I am routing for Blake, Gina, and Melinda (the hometown girl)! I like them all, but I think Melinda is absolutely awesome!!!

Sanjaya Malakar, 17, Federal Way, Wash.: It’s like Malakar knows that he can’t do anything to get voted off the show, and wants to test exactly how far he can press his luck. He picked “Bathwater” by No Doubt, sang with what looked like a dead bird on his head, and was pretty much a mess until the last 10 seconds of the song. “It’s a hard song, and he chose it … so good luck for him,” Stefani said before the performance. But clearly Malakar already has more luck than a gaggle of leprechauns, or he would have been gone weeks ago. Grade: DStay or go? “I don’t think it matters what we say anymore,” Simon said. He’s probably right. But there’s no reason that he should still be around next week if voters make their pick based on performance.